The prevailing theory of organic structure in the early 19th century was Dualism or the Electrochemical Theory, principally championed by Berzelius. Since inorganic sodium chloride could be considered as Na⁺Cl^-, then an alkyl halide such as RCl could be thought of as R⁺Cl^-. The R group or "radical" of its day, was thought to be immutable, the carbons and hydrogens behaving as though they were an element. Liebig (German) and Dumas (French), influential chemists of the day, published a joint paper (1837), On the Present State of Organic Chemistry, extolling the concept and claiming all that was left to do in organic chemistry was to identify these immutable radicals (benzoyl, ethyl, acetyl, etc.) As the story goes, a Parisian reception at the Tuileries was to change all of this. The guests were discomforted by fumes from the burning candles. Dumas was called in as a consultant. He found that the waxes (fatty esters) had exchanged chlorine for hydrogen, the culprit being the by-product hydrogen chloride.

The concept of exchanging electropositive hydrogen for electronegative chlorine was anathema to dualism. Liebig was not enamored with substitution. Why? After all Liebig and Wöhler had done precisely this in 1832 during their work on the benzoyl radical (C₇H₅O). They had converted benzaldehyde [(C₇H₅O)H] into benzoyl chloride [(C₇H₅O)Cl] by the action of chlorine. So disenchanted with the controversies regarding theory in organic chemistry was Liebig, by 1840 he turned his attention to the practical applications of agricultural chemistry. Thus was born Liebig beef extract.

Dumas's student, Laurent, not one to shirk from controversy, was bold enough to call the process substitution rather than exchange. Thus was Substitution Theory born. Moreover, Dumas (1838) was able to substitute three of the four hydrogens of acetic acid for chlorine to form trichloroacetic acid, having similar properties to acetic acid. The recognition of these similar properties led to early Type Theory. In 1842, Melsen, a student of Dumas, reversed Dumas's experiment by reducing trichloroacetic acid to acetic acid by the action of zinc metal. The promulgation of Substitution Theory gave the wry wit of Wöhler, a.k.a., S. C. H. Windler, an opportunity to shine. At the (beginning) turn of the 20th century free radicals were detected and named free radicals to distinguish them from the older radicals of Radical Theory of the early 19th century. during the 19th century chemists tried to isolate the older radicals to no avail. When they (Kolbe and Frankland) thought they had isolated methyl, they actually had the dimer of methyl, ethane. The very process of substituting chlorine for hydrogen is a free radical reaction.